City of Annemasse reduces the Energy Consumption by Renovating 6 Public Buildings

The City of Annemasse renovated 6 Public Buildings through Energy Performance Contracting (EPC), in order to commit to the reduction of the Energy Consumption of its Building Stock.

As part of its Agenda 21, the City of Annemasse has committed to reducing the energy consumption of its building stock by renovating 6 public buildings. The expected reductions in consumption have been guaranteed by an Energy Performance Contract since 2013.​

The Project in Brief

Energy performance target: Energy consumption: -24.77% – GHG emissions: -29%
Duration: 8 years
Investment: €487 k Excl. VAT
Type of EPC: Supplies and services
Contracting authority: SETEC
Consortium representative: Energy service company SPIE Facilities
Type of buildings: 6 public buildings: the town hall dating from the end of the 19th century; 3 school complexes built or renovated in 1970, 2000, and 2009; a sports facility built in 2010; the Martin Luther King multi-purpose complex (rooms for conferences and community organisations), for a total surface area of 21,500 m2.

A cross-border city just outside Geneva

The City of Annemasse began addressing environmental issues in 1997, and decided to incorporate sustainable development principles into its municipal practices in 1999. It embarked on an Agenda 21 programme in 2000, which led to the adoption of an initial action plan in 2005 that was later revisited in 2009.

In 2016, Annemasse Agglo launched a Territorial Climate Air and Energy Plan (SEAP) to establish a comprehensive strategy for climate action and reduce energy consumption. The municipal government won the “Positive Energy Territory for Green Growth” (TEPCV) request for proposals.

In 2012, the design office SETEC audited the City of Annemasse’s properties, identifying the 6 most energy- intensive sites: two recent buildings (the 2010 sports facility and the Saint-Exupéry school built in 2009) whose energy performances did not meet expectations, and 4 older buildings (the town hall dating from the end of the 19th century, the Martin Luther King complex, a primary school renovated in 2000, and a school complex built in the 1970s without insulation or double glazing). The need to make better use of the newer buildings and have guaranteed energy savings following renovation of the older building stock became clear. To that end, an Energy Performance Contract was launched in 2013 for the 6 buildings.

Objective

The EPC is an 8-year contract to reduce energy consumption through energy management, optimisation, and investments in technical facilities as well as their operation, small and large maintenance work, and the updating of energy systems. The EPC was chosen for its guaranteed results.

The minimum energy reduction target in the City of Annemasse’s public tender was 23%. In the end, the operator SPIE’s final offer was a 24.77% reduction in energy consumption and a 29% in reduction in CO2 emissions. The baseline was established using actual consumption data from 2008 to 2011.

Implementation

MAIN STAGES:

July 2013 – Contractualisation: Launch of the EPC (signature of the contract)
October 2013 – End of the work

This EPC applies to work on the heating installations. It does not apply to the actual buildings. The consortium representative, SPIE, can benefit from Energy Savings Certificates (ESC) for any eligible actions taken. ESC is a system in which public authorities require energy sellers (electricity, gas, heating and cooling, domestic heating oil, etc.) to achieve energy savings by actively promoting energy efficiency among their customers and other energy consumers (households, local governments, professionals).

The energy saving actions include:

  • Replacement of oil-fired boilers with natural gas condensing boilers

  • Replacement of existing high-power natural gas boilers with condensing boilers for better management of needs

  • Implementation of a Centralised Technical Management (CTM) system that is accessible online

  • Management of occupation patterns and temperature adjustments based on intermittent occupation, particularly in school buildings

  • Replacement of pumps and valves to regulate circuits

SPIE, the operator, is responsible for all the investments and is paying itself with the profits obtained. Part of its annual remuneration is a fixed rate (€52,000 Excl. VAT/year for operations-maintenance and the total P2 and P3 guarantee). It also receives payment for the totality of the energy savings realised based on an average cost per kWh if the target of 24.77% is met. If the target is exceeded, the surplus will be shared by the city and SPIE.

However, if the performance target is not met, the payment is reduced by the percentage of savings not attained multiplied by the coefficient of penalties, which increases from 1.1 to 2 during the 8 years of the EPC. SPIE is responsible for controls and verifications in its intervention area. The protocol is based on monthly readings of the energy meters (gas and electricity).

At the end of each heating period, the annual energy savings realised are calculated using the protocol for measuring and verifying the energy performance.

Results

All the planned work was completed in 2013. Additional work was conducted in 2014 and 2015: replacement of thermostatic valves, balancing of networks, and replacement of equipment as part of the contract’s total guarantee.

The energy savings results were:

Season Savings Savings in KWh
2013-2014 29% 1,208,045
2014-2015 23,4% 919,359
2015-2016 30,2% 1,305,000
2016-2017 28,6% 1,280,321
2017-2018 25,7% 1,067,053

Difficulties

  • The short time frame between the awarding of the contract and the beginning of the first heating season required that work be conducted quickly.
  • The application of requirements to maintain a temperature of 20°C in poorly insulated premises, without having a record of the settings used to establish the baseline consumption for the EPC, resulted in reduced comfort and the dissatisfaction of some occupants, meaning the energy savings programme was not well received.

Next steps

In 2016, the City of Annemasse launched a second EPC for 5 sites belonging to the city or the Community Welfare Centre (a home for the elderly, a community centre including an MJC [youth and cultural centre], an early childhood centre and music school, two school complexes, and a gymnasium). This EPC was awarded to IDEX Énergies with a target of 500,000 kWh in annual savings.


About


Country :
France
Region :
Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes Region
Time frame :
2013 - 2021
Website :
cpeauvergnerhonealpes.org
Download

Document produced by AURA-EE with the support of the Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes region, ADEME and the EU.
Fiche_CPE_batiments_Annemasse-eng.pdf

Organisation Name Position Contact
Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes Énergie Environnement (AURA-EE) Laurent Chanussot Head of Sustainable Buildings info@auvergnerhonealpes-ee.fr